but what of GRACE?
i began the day on a happy note...until i discovered at work that the person who injured my neck would be dismissed from school. i was very troubled...i still am. i mean, he's just about 5 weeks shy of graduation..and now he must stop. Lord please dont let him be angry or bitter with the leadership, or me, or even himself. please help him get over this, Lord.
everyone above me tells me i did the right thing by reporting...and even after a short discussion with my boss, i still feel there's something else that can be done. if only they would understand how i feel. i know i did the right thing by reporting the incident...but i didnt mean for all this to happen. i want him to be able to stay and finish his program, but how can i vouch for him without reporting it as it is to the authorities, which i was obliged to as part of my duties?
i was made to understand that he has had several unpleasant encounters with authorities...obviously, all things were considered before his dismissal, including those encounters. they say that this incident would be a great lesson for him. i do not doubt it. yet i believe that people learn their greatest lessons when they know they were wrong and are willing to accept the given consequences without argument. (and how many people in this world are actually that humble?) but this is where, i believe, we mess up: sometimes we serve consequences that are not corresponding or consistent with what happened just because it is stated in policies and rules.
what about more grace? how about letting him remain in school under probation, closer supervision, tighter restrictions? what about more accountability?
school is a place where we come to learn and change. and especially in this school, it's a place where our characters are challenged, our values are tested, our perspectives broadened, to be trained, transformed. but what happens when all these possibilities are refused? doesnt it defeat the purpose of school? cold-turkey-get-out-of-here-you-made-a-terrible-mistake-dismissal-*boot!* decisions, in my opinion based on this situation, would lead to two outcomes:
(i) the person realizes that he was wrong, and encourages himself to learn from this mistake. he looks to God for strength and direction and comfort. but in order for this to happen, he must have character enough to receive correction. he would be a person of more character if he would just accept correction, no matter how severe. and when he does accepts the consequences (which, by the way, as much as it is in the power of those that give it, should be given accordingly; and i think in this case it is not) then a big life lesson is learnt and he is the wiser because of it. and his heart becomes softened and more receptive to what God is doing in him.
or
(ii) the person is unwilling to accept the consequences even though he knows he was wrong and even though he has apologised. he is unwilling because he feels that the consequences are too harsh; to him, he has stooped low enough to admit his mistake and say sorry - so therefore he will stand his ground. and if he is forced to comply and given no alternative, then we have created a monster in him by pushing him to a corner where he has no choice but to retaliate; and retaliation is always ugly when it is not reasonably thought-over. and by this time, of course, the worst of his character is no longer just scratching, but now mauling and pommeling everything that, to him, seeks to destroy him and his future (when of course, we meant it for his own good...or do we?) And his heart? ...hardened.
what then is the challenge for us as leadership?
i would say that it is to bring the person in the wrong before (ii) happens and lead him to the place where his heart and character is willing (i): "yes, i was wrong, forgive me, i receive correction". what does it hurt when a person is willing to change for the better? and what does it benefit when a person becomes hardened and closed in his heart?
some points from the Word of God and other sources:
"Now if your brother sins against you, be going, and show him his fault between you and him alone, if he hears you, you gained your brother. But if he does not hear [you], take along with you yet one or two, so that 'by [the] mouth of two or three witnesses every word shall be established.' [Deuteronomy 19:15] But if he refuses to listen to them, tell [it] to the assembly [or, church]; but if he also refuses to listen to the assembly, he shall be to you just like the heathen and the tax collector." (Mat 18:15-17 Analytical-Literal Translation)
and who are the heathen and tax collector to us but people who need more grace?
"If he still won't listen, tell the church. If he won't listen to the church, you'll have to start over from scratch, confront him with the need for repentance, and offer again God's forgiving love." (Mat 18:17 The Message)
"You shall not hate your brother in your heart. You shall always rebuke your neighbour, and not allow sin on him." (Leviticus 19:17 Modern King James Version)
"rebuke, יכח yâkach yaw-kakh'
A primitive root; to be right (that is, correct); reciprocally to argue; causatively to decide, justify or convict: - appoint, argue, chasten, convince, correct (-ion), daysman, dispute, judge, maintain, plead, reason (together), rebuke, reprove (-r), surely, in any wise." (H3198 Strong's Concordance)
"Janganlah engkau membenci saudaramu di dalam hatimu, tetapi engkau harus berterus terang menegor orang sesamamu dan janganlah engkau mendatangkan dosa kepada dirimu karena dia." (Imamat 19:17 Indonesia Terjemahan Baru)
"Do not nurse hatred in your heart for any of your relatives. Confront your neighbours directly so you will not be held guilty for their crimes." (Leviticus 19:17 New Living Translation)
"Why is confrontation so difficult? We often misunderstand its purpose. Our goal should not be to punish or excommunicate, but to restore. Confrontation is a redemptive act of leadership." (John C. Maxwell on 1 Corinthians 5:1-13, The Maxwell Leadership Bible)
Lord...help me...please tell me how i can help in this situation! Tell me what i should do, O Lord!
*all views on this post are based on my reflections upon the Word of God and how i feel about the current situation i'm facing.